9 Gifts for a Baby’s First Christmas That Are Not Clutter
A first Christmas is mostly naps.
That is not a complaint, it is the planning information. A baby of four months has no idea what day it is, will not remember any of it, and will spend a good part of the afternoon asleep on somebody. So everything bought for the occasion is really bought for the adults. That is fine as long as everybody is honest about it, because it changes what a good present is.
A good present for a first Christmas is something that is still being used in March.
Nine picks in three groups. Ratings are live Amazon ratings, never ours.
- 1
A structured newborn carrierBest if you only buy one thing - 2A soft carrier for 0 to 12 monthsBest for a smaller newborn
- 3A cot soother with a heartbeat settingBest for the four month wall
- 4A projector soother that plays underwater scenesBest for a baby who wakes at 5am
- 5A star projector with white noiseBest for a shared room
- 6A bedtime picture book that lasts to school ageBest gift under twenty dollars
- 7A board book about going to bedBest for the routine itself
- 8A board book about napsBest for a daytime sleep that is not working
- 9A rhyming book about a dragon who will not sleepBest for reading out loud
Group one
The one thing that changes a whole day
If there is one purchase that alters what a day with a small baby feels like, it is a carrier. It turns an hour of standing in a kitchen holding a baby into an hour of doing something with a baby attached. It also earns its place on the day itself, when the house is full and the baby is not interested in being passed around.
BabyBjrn Baby Carrier Mini
As an Amazon Associate, Decoded Kids earns from qualifying purchases. Price checked live on Amazon.
Structured or soft is largely a question of what the wearer’s back prefers and how big the baby is. Anyone who is going to be wearing it for long stretches usually ends up preferring a structured one. Smaller newborns and shorter trips suit a soft one better.
Group two
The ones aimed at the hours nobody photographs
The second group exists for five in the morning. This is the part of a first year that gets almost no attention on a gift list and takes up more of the actual experience than anything else on it.
VTech Communications BC8211 Myla The Monkey Baby Sleep Soother with
Soothers with a steady sound and a low light do two separate jobs. They give the baby something consistent. They also give the adult in the room a way to settle them without turning the main light on, which is the thing that ends a night at four in the morning.
One caution worth stating plainly. Nothing here goes inside the cot with the baby, and nothing here is a sleep aid in the medical sense. Our piece on the baby sleep products not to buy covers the ones with genuine safety questions attached, and sleep regression explained covers why the four month version of this arrives whatever you own.
Group three
The ones that are still in the house in five years
Board books are the best value item on any first Christmas list and they are consistently the least exciting to give, which is why people talk themselves out of them.
They survive being chewed, thrown and stood on. They get read three hundred times. And they are still in use when the child is four. By then the baby who was handed it can recite it.
Read-aloud rhythm matters more than the story at this age, because the baby is listening to a voice rather than following a plot. Books that scan properly out loud get picked up again by the adult, which is what decides whether a book gets read.
What we would not buy for a first Christmas
Clothes in the size they are now. By the time the wrapping is off, that size has about three weeks left in it. Buy the next size up, or the one after that, in the season it will actually be.
A giant soft toy. It cannot go in the cot, it is too big to take anywhere, and it lives in a corner of the room for a decade. A small one that can be washed and duplicated is a far better idea.
Anything that promises longer sleep. Weighted products in particular. There are real safety questions here, and a first Christmas is not the moment to experiment with them.
The honest caveat: we have not tested every item here in our own homes. Ratings are live Amazon ratings pulled from our product library rather than typed in by us, and nothing in this list is safe-sleep advice.
More for the first year
Questions parents ask
What should you buy for a baby’s first Christmas?
Something still in use in March. A carrier changes the shape of every day. A soother helps at the hours nobody photographs. Board books are the only category here a four year old will still ask for.
Is it worth buying a baby presents when they will not remember it?
The baby will not remember it, so buy for the year rather than the day. That is not cynical, it is the most useful filter there is, and it rules out almost everything that ends up in a cupboard by February.
What should you avoid buying for a newborn at Christmas?
Clothes in the size they wear now. Giant soft toys that cannot go in the cot or out of the house. And anything marketed as helping a baby sleep longer. The last one carries real safety questions and a first Christmas is not the time to test them.
Leave the first comment
Share your thoughts
I'm for the parent doing it largely alone. I've done the single-dad decade - two homes, one income, the handovers, the very quiet Tuesdays - and I write from the far side of most of those days, with humour and hard-won calm. Not advice from above; a hand back from a few steps up the road.
More from DiegoWhat's the one thing that actually calmed the chaos in your house?
No right answers here - tell us how it actually went. Someone reading needs to hear it.
Join the conversation