He Built It in One Afternoon and Never Touched It Again
It is on top of the wardrobe now. The thing he built last Christmas, fully assembled, finished in about forty minutes, dusty.
That is the actual failure mode of most science kits, and it has nothing to do with whether your child likes science. A kit that builds one object is a craft project with a lab coat on the box. It gets built once, and then it is an ornament. The ten below are sorted by what a child does with their hands rather than by age, because a nine year old who takes the remote apart and a nine year old who wants a clean set of instructions need completely different boxes.
The thing worth holding onto while you shop is a line from Kathy Hirsh-Pasek, the Temple University psychologist behind a lot of the research on how children actually learn through play. It is the quickest test there is for a box with STEM printed on it.
- 1
Snap Circuits BeginnerGets rebuilt, which is the whole test - 2
Mega Cyborg HandYou wear the thing you built - 3
Smartivity Rocket LauncherBuild it, then argue about angles - 4
Magic Chemistry SetTen tricks, so there is a reason to repeat them - 5
Melican 60+ Experiment KitVolume, for a younger one who wants another go - 6
GobiDex Gemstone Dig KitSlow on purpose, and cheap - 7
Nat Geo MicroscopeTurns the whole house into the kit - 8
Outdoor Exploration KitFor the one who wants to go and look - 9
Glow-in-the-Dark Marble RunNo finished state to reach - 10
The LEGO Ideas BookFor the bricks already under the sofa
Band one
For the one who takes things apart
You know this child because something in your house is already in pieces. The instinct is to find out what is inside, and a kit that ends in one sealed finished object fights that instinct instead of feeding it.
What you want here is anything that comes apart again without breaking.
SNAP CIRCUITS Beginner SCB-20 STEM Electronics Toy for Kids Ages 5-9
As an Amazon Associate, Decoded Kids earns from qualifying purchases. Price checked live on Amazon.
The pieces click onto a grid and the manual has around a hundred different circuits in it. A light, a fan, an alarm that goes off when you walk past. It is the one product on this list that still gets pulled out two years later, because there is no point at which it is finished.
A hydraulic hand you build and then strap to your arm. The build is a proper afternoon, the tubes and syringes are the actual lesson, and wearing it is what makes them show it to everyone who comes to the door.
Cardboard and elastic, launches a small rocket across the garden. It is the cheapest thing in this band and the one most likely to turn into an argument about launch angles, which is the point.
Band two
For the one who wants a mess and a result
This child does not care how it works yet. They care that something happened, and they want it to happen again immediately.
Buy for repeats, then. A kit with one spectacular experiment in it is a five minute gift. A kit with forty small ones is a wet Sunday in February, and you will want that Sunday.
Put a tray under all of it and a towel next to it before you hand it over. That one move is the difference between a happy mess and you standing at the sink at nine at night.
Ten tricks, each with a real bit of chemistry behind it and a performance attached. The performing is what makes a child do it four times, and doing it four times is when they start asking why.
Sixty-odd experiments aimed younger, roughly four to eight. Less polished than the Nat Geo boxes and that is fine here, because what you are buying is the number of goes.
Chipping gemstones out of a block of plaster is slow, dusty and weirdly absorbing. Do it outside. The digging is the gift, not the stones.
Band three
For the one who would rather look than build
Some kids do not want to make anything. They want to find out. Handing that child a construction kit is a mismatch, and they tend to be the ones written off as not being into science.
The slides it comes with get used once. What matters is everything after that: a hair, a bit of onion, pond water, the dust off a windowsill. It turns your whole house into the kit, which is exactly the 90 percent child and 10 percent toy thing.
Binoculars, a compass, a magnifier and a bug pot. Nothing clever, and that is why it keeps going out of the door. If screens are what you are really trying to compete with, our screen-free gift list is built entirely around things with no off switch to argue about.
Band four
For the one who builds without instructions
The giveaway is a child who follows the manual once and then pushes it aside. They are not being difficult. A finished model is a dead end to them.
National Geographic Glow-in-the-Dark Marble Run for Kids Ages 8-12
Marble runs have no correct answer, so there is no moment where it is done. This one glows, which means it gets rebuilt at bedtime, which you may or may not thank me for.
If there are already bricks in the house, a book of ideas beats another set. It gives a child who has run out of things to make somewhere to start without telling them what to build. We went deeper into that pile in the guide for the kid who only wants one more set.
And the one already on top of the wardrobe
Before you buy anything, go and get the kit from last year down. Not to make them finish it. Most of those boxes still have three quarters of their parts in them, and the parts are the useful bit once the instructions have been abandoned.
Tip the whole lot into a shallow tray with whatever else is lying around, the marble run pieces, a roll of tape, some straws. What you are doing is taking away the correct answer. A child who found the manual boring will often spend an hour on the same components once nobody is checking the picture on the box.
It also tells you something before you spend money. If they light up with a pile of loose parts, buy from band one or band four. If they put it down again within a minute and ask what it is supposed to make, band two is your shelf.
What we would skip
Kits that build exactly one thing. The crystal that grows once, the volcano that erupts once, the model that is glued. They photograph well and they are finished before the wrapping paper is in the bin. If it cannot be taken apart, assume one afternoon and price it accordingly.
Anything that needs an app to work. You are adding a screen, a login and a software update to a present, and in two years the app will be gone and the toy will be a brick.
A coding robot for a child who has not asked for one. These sell on what a parent hopes will happen. If your kid has shown no interest in code, a robot will not create it, and there are enough unused things in the house already.
One question worth asking before you buy any of them
What does your child do when nobody has given them anything to do? Take things apart, make a mess, go and look, or build. That answer is worth more than every age range printed on every box, and it is also why a gift that suits the cousin can flop completely in your house. If you would rather shop by age anyway, the eight to ten list is laid out that way.
If your question is a bit different
Leave the first comment
Share your thoughts
Frequently asked questions
The good ones are, and the label is not what makes them good. What matters is whether the thing can be used more than one way. A kit that builds a single finished object gets used once, while anything that comes apart and goes back together keeps earning its shelf space.
Most boxes say eight and up, which is about reading the manual rather than the science. A five year old will happily do the same experiments with you reading it aloud. Sort by what your child likes doing with their hands instead, because that predicts use far better than the age on the box.
Usually they mean school science is boring, which is a different thing. Skip anything that looks like a lesson and buy a tool instead, like a microscope or a bug pot. Letting them point it at whatever they want puts them in charge, and that is normally where the interest comes back.
I'm for the parent about to spend money they're not sure about. I buy the gadget, live with it, and give you the honest verdict - including the 'don't'. I've burned through enough hype to save you the cash, and when something truly earns its place, I'll show you exactly why.
More from TylerWhat's the one thing that actually calmed the chaos in your house?
No right answers here - tell us how it actually went. Someone reading needs to hear it.
Join the conversation